By Carol J. Loomis
FORTUNE -- Results are in for the sixth year of the competition sometimes called the $1 million bet, and Warren Buffett -- once a piteous straggler in this 10-year wager on stock market performance -- has opened up a sizable lead over his opponent, New York asset manager Protégé Partners. Buffett's horse in the bet is a low-cost S&P index fund, and Protégé's is the averaged returns to investors (after all fees) of five hedge funds of funds that the firm carefully picked for the contest.
At the end of 2013, Vanguard's Admiral shares -- the S&P index fund that's carrying Buffett's colors -- were up for the six years that began Jan. 1, 2008 by 43.8%. For the same period, Protégé's five funds of funds, on the average, gained only by an estimated 12.5% (a figure minutely uncertain because some of the funds lack final figures for 2013).
By the terms of the bet, the names of those five funds of funds have never been publicly disclosed (though Buffett knows their identity). It has always been assumed that one of the five is a hedge fund of funds run by Protégé itself.
As for the $1 million moniker, it comes from the amount that was ultimately to be delivered to a charity picked by the winner. Buffett's designee is Girls Inc. of Omaha, and Protégé's is Absolute Returns for Kids.
That $1 million, though, had some present-value mathematics behind it. Each side in the bet put up about $320,000, and the total was invested in zero-coupon bonds that at the contest's end would be worth $1 million.
But in the low interest-rate climate that enveloped the Great Recession, the zero-coupon bonds took off like a heat-seeking rocket. By the end of 2012, the bonds were close to their ultimate value, $1 million, which meant their appreciation potential was almost nil.
So Buffett and Protégé partner Ted Seides reworked the bet, agreeing that the bonds would be sold and the proceeds put into Berkshire Hathaway stock (BRKA). That switch took place just as the great American stock market year of 2013 was coming on. S&P's Admiral Shares, with dividends included, rose by 32.3% during the year; Berkshire stock, which pays no dividend, beat the index by a nose, gaining 32.7%. By the end of the year, the amount slated for the winning charity was close to $1,270,000.
Meanwhile, most hedge funds were doing what hedge funds do -- hedging by shorting some stocks, investing in other geographies (like emerging markets), and along the way imposing their biting costs on their investors. The five funds backed by Protégé appear to have followed that crowd: They gained only 11.8% in 2013.
"We've got our work cut out for us," said Protégé's Seides last weekend, as he contemplated the four years remaining in the bet. And on the next day of trading -- that would be Monday -- the stock market pitched downward, and, wherever they were, the shorts made money.
Carol Loomis, the writer of this article, is a longtime friend of Warren Buffett and a Berkshire Hathaway stockholder.
Fortune senior editor-at-large will mark her 60th year at the magazine in January.
By Anne VanderMey, reporter
FORTUNE -- Fortune senior editor-at-large Carol Loomis -- CEO whisperer and scourge of creative corporate accountants -- was inducted into the Deadline Club's New York Journalism Hall of Fame on Thursday.
She was one of eight journalists honored over lunch at Sardi's, joining a club that includes Mike Wallace, Gloria Steinem, and Barbara Walters. Other MORENov 14, 2013 1:42 PM ET
Companies change with the times, and newspapers are no different. But they are now emerging in a strong position.Aug 22, 2013 12:09 PM ET
In its seventh redesign of the storied sporty two-seater, GM has a chance to show off its engineering chops and its corporate revival.Aug 20, 2013 5:00 AM ET
With demand for the metal on the rise, are investors like Berkshire Hathaway starting a "tungsten rush?"
By Alex Konrad, reporter
FORTUNE -- Tungsten, one of the hardest metals in the world and used for everything from drill bits to light bulbs to touch screens, is suddenly hot. Much of the increased demand is coming from China, which just happens to hold the world's biggest reserves. The country is hoarding mineral resources MOREApr 3, 2012 5:00 AM ET
With 90% of U.S. rail freight now controlled by only four companies, shippers claim the giants have unfairly banded together. Unapologetic railroads refuse to back down. An epic battle of business vs. business.
By Mina Kimes, writer
FORTUNE -- From the roof of M&G Polymers' factory in Apple Grove, W.Va., the freight trains on the ground look like children's toys. Several hundred cars wait to be filled with tiny pellets destined to become plastic containers. Every evening, MORESep 13, 2011 5:00 AM ET
Editor's note: Every week, Fortune.com publishes a favorite story from our magazine archives. Today we turn to banking giant Bank of America, which this week saw a much-need vote of confidence from billionaire investor Warren Buffett. Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway is swooping in to reassure markets once again by investing $5 billion in Bank of America, allaying widespread fears that the biggest U.S. bank lacks sufficient capital. This article from 1947 looks MOREAug 28, 2011 8:20 AM ET
Want to know what Warren Buffett's buying? Or any other major stock player? One small investor has a site for you.
By Scott Cendrowski, reporter
FORTUNE -- Like many people, Charlie Tian loaded up on tech stocks in the '90s. A scientist at Fujitsu, he thought he knew the sector. Then the market crash proved he didn't. Tian, 43, figured there was a better way for small investors. He started reading Warren MOREAug 16, 2011 5:00 AM ET
[ Intro | 1-25 | 26-50 | 51-75 | 75-100 ]
26. Ben & Jerry's
The only thing better than its AmeriCone Dream is the "flavor graveyard" on its website.
27. Bose noise-canceling headphones
It took a Massachusetts company to make ignoring your neighbor on an airplane socially acceptable.
28. Self-stick stamps
Our tongues are rejoicing.
29. The Boeing 747
The most popular commercial aircraft in history.
30. Warren Buffett
Even after Sokolgate, he's still the Oracle, and friend to the likes MORE
[ Intro | 1-25 | 26-50 | 51-75 | 75-100 ]
Stainless steel, swivel counter stools, and breakfast anytime.
77. Old Spice
Those quirky ads brought it back into the public eye, but the iconic red stick has been sweetening your scent since 1938.
78. Disneyland/Disney World
Parents and kids simply say they're "going to Disney."
79. Philly cheesesteaks
Pat's, Geno's -- or Jim's. Often imitated, never duplicated.
80. Xerox PARC
The Silicon Valley lab where Ethernet and laser printing MORE
|The medical marijuana ad that never aired, despite contrary media headlines|
|2 million students missing out on college aid|
|GM raising Corvette prices|
|China to fight pollution with drones|
|Boeing reports wing cracks on Dreamliners|